THE LATEST:  Tigers Win On Rocky Top

The Unwritten Rules Must Go

Posted by Matt on June 4, 2014

Baseball may be the only sport where the actual rules of the game are eclipsed by a rulebook nobody can read.For over a century, the “unwritten rules” of baseball spell out mostly what not to do, in some attempt to standardize respect for an opponent. Tim Kurkjian has written a great piece at about the rulebook you can’t find in print, and tries to cobble together a list of the most obvious infractions:

  • Do not cross the line showing off your home run.
  • In retaliation, there will be blood (or at least a Rawlings tattoo)
  • No stealing bases when you’re up 10-0
  • No bunting to break up a no-hitter
  • Never swing on a 3-0 count when your team leads big

Of course, two of the last three make sense to speed up a game that has already been decided. Everybody has dinner reservations they’d like to make, after all. But most of the unwritten rules are archaic. They aren’t needed in a modern game.

Do people watch the NFL for conservative run plays to keep a blowout moving? Nope. They watch to see very large men hit other very large men, and scoring plays. The NBA doesn’t make a highlight reel of high-percentage jumpers at the end of the season. Flair makes the game exciting to the fans and the players, but baseball tries to stifle it with the “unwritten rules.”

I actually have no problem with one part of baseball’s silent code: as long as you aren’t throwing at someone’s head, throw beanballs at them all you want. The value of a run is so great, that that extra baserunner may make you pay in the end… and you run the risk of the umpire issuing you a cold shower.

But the actions that are supposedly the reason for a beanball war? Pretty mild. Observing a home run or bat-flipping is tolerated by some players, but not others. So why should any pitcher take offense when the standard is inconsistent? Same goes for bunting to break up a no-hitter. Pitchers should be shown no mercy in that spot, because bunting is a part of the game. A player can bunt in the first inning and not be hated for it, but in the eighth it is a crime? Give me a break.

Overall, baseball’s traditions are great. They’re part of the fabric of the game. But I think new traditions can be alright, too. And whatever you do… put the doggone rules on paper next time.

-Matt Michaels



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *